A second judicial review and a new court date

On 4 June 2026, the High Court ruled that the decision to introduce England’s Genetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Regulations 2025 had been made unlawfully. The Court found that the minister responsible, Daniel Zeichner, had been wrongly advised about his power to require labelling and traceability of genetically engineered precision-bred organisms (PBOs).

That misunderstanding constrained the options he considered and the enquiries he made. The judgment also recognised that without labelling it would be significantly harder for the organic sector to maintain its standards – and for consumers who wish to avoid precision-bred PBOs, to do so.

Defra’s secret decision

The Court did not immediately decide what should happen to the Regulations. It invited both sides to make submissions on a remedy. Defra argued that the Regulations should remain in place, relying in part on a “discrete” decision taken by newly appointed farming minister Stephen Morgan on 23 June 2026 to maintain the existing regime.

The decision – taken just 11 days after he took up his new position – was not made public; Beyond GM and the other claimants learned of it through Defra’s court submissions.

Beyond GM and its co-claimants have now brought a second related judicial review to challenge that decision. The legal papers are now in the public domain, allowing us, finally, to explain the grounds of the claim.

No consultation, bad information

Our claim argues that the decision was made without fair consultation; that Morgan was not given a fair and balanced briefing or the information needed to make proper enquiries; that the decision relied on a misdirection about the scope of labelling powers under the Food Safety Act 1990; and that keeping the decision unpublished amounted to operating an unpublished policy.

Defra disputes these claims.

New PBO foods in the pipeline

The case has real world consequences while the Regulations remain in operation. Since the June judgment, Beyond GM has tracked eight experimental PBO field-trial notices and five PBO marketing notices granted by the government. The Food Standards Agency is also assessing three applications for unlabelled and untraceable PBO foods: wheat, strawberries and bananas. These developments underscore why the Court’s decision on the remedy matters to farmers, food businesses, organic producers and consumers.

A new court date – and more work to do

Our previously scheduled hearing date has changed. The new hearing in the High Court on 17-18 March 2027, will bring together the remedy stage of the first judicial review and the second judicial review.

Thank you to everyone who has supported this work so far. Our two cases are central to securing lawful decision-making and meaningful accountability, and to protecting the ability of farmers, businesses and consumers to know where PBOs are being used. We hope you all will continue to donate to Beyond GM’s legal fund in this extraordinary case.

Tell Your Friends

Posted

in

by